New York: New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has unveiled a renewed plan to close the notorious Rikers Island jail complex by 2032, proposing the construction of four smaller detention facilities and measures to significantly reduce the city’s prison population.
The proposal aims to transform New York City’s detention system by replacing the ageing Rikers Island facility with smaller, more accessible jails designed to improve conditions for detainees and their families.
Dana Kaplan, appointed by Mamdani as the city’s official overseeing the closure of Rikers Island, described the proposal as a generational opportunity to rethink how people are detained. Kaplan remarked that the initiative goes beyond replacing an outdated facility and offers an opportunity to establish a more appropriate and effective detention system.
Located on a 413-acre island between Queens and the Bronx, Rikers Island has faced longstanding criticism over deteriorating infrastructure, staff shortages, poor living conditions and inmate deaths. The complex currently houses more than 6,500 inmates at any given time, while the mayor’s administration aims to reduce the population to approximately 4,100.
However, the proposed reduction has drawn criticism from the New York City Correction Officers’ Benevolent Association. The union warned that imposing a limit on available jail beds could threaten public safety, arguing that maintaining the proposed population level could require the release of individuals facing violent felony charges.
Kaplan rejected the concerns, maintaining that reducing the number of people held in city jails is achievable and should be a central objective of the administration’s reform efforts. Efforts to close Rikers Island date back to 2019, when the New York City Council voted to shut down the complex by 2027. However, implementation faced repeated delays due to logistical challenges, including difficulties identifying suitable locations for replacement facilities. Mamdani attributed the setbacks partly to delays under former Mayor Eric Adams’ administration and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Under the latest proposal, the city plans to establish four new detention facilities. A jail in Brooklyn is scheduled to open by 2029, followed by two facilities in the Bronx and Queens by 2031. The fourth facility, in Manhattan, is expected to be completed by 2032. The revised timeline will require approval from the New York City Council.
The mayor’s office stated that the smaller facilities would offer better access to natural daylight, fresh air and cleaner surroundings. Their locations are also expected to make visits easier for families, who often face lengthy journeys to reach the remote Rikers Island complex.
The administration also plans to reduce reliance on detention through alternative programmes for people awaiting trial, expand online bail payment options for families and accelerate pretrial legal proceedings. In addition, it aims to establish hundreds of therapeutic housing beds for detainees experiencing serious mental health conditions.
Kaplan added that the administration had already opened 100 therapeutic beds at Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan, allowing 100 people to be moved out of Rikers Island. The proposal also includes an investment of $146 million in mental health and substance use treatment, alongside vocational training and educational programmes both inside and outside detention facilities.
In an 88-page report released, Mamdani described Rikers Island as a facility marked by deteriorating infrastructure and said closing the complex was a moral imperative. The jail has also been the subject of federal intervention, with a judge appointing an independent official last year to oversee operations and decisions concerning the facility. The latest proposal represents a renewed effort to end decades of controversy surrounding Rikers Island and reshape the future of incarceration in New York City.

